Individuals begin forming “impressions” from the first point of contact in the interview process. Some are subtle. Others are more pronounced, making an indelible impact. In aggregate, these impressions form an opinion…good or bad. 

Interestingly, companies often place a disproportionate amount of emphasis on the experience of the individual who ends up getting the job, whilst very little attention is paid to the experience of those who went deep into the process but didn’t secure an offer. This would seemingly make sense. The former is the person whom the company is most trying to woo into the organization. However, there is a flaw in this logic.

The individual who accepts an offer will, by default, have a positive impression because they received a favorable outcome. The 1, 2, or 3 other individuals who did not are the ones more prone to having a poor opinion of the company and will share it with the broader market. This is the axis on which a company’s recruiting brand rotates. 

While not always easy, this is avoidable. Below are 10 key tenets of conducting a successful recruiting process. If consistently executed over time, these will establish a strong recruiting brand for the company.

1.  Job descriptions/ads/postings should not be written like a laundry list of unrealistic “must haves” for the individual to be lucky enough to apply for the role. Instead, list the bare minimum in terms of “ideal” qualifications.  You want to screen individuals in versus out in this stage of the process.  Sometimes, the best individual will not be the most qualified one.  You still want them to apply, right?

2. Provide leaders time in their day to prepare for interviews. Shockingly, many interviewers don’t even review the individual’s resume before the interview starts. This is evident to the interviewee.

3. Ensure those conducting interviews arrive on time, stay within the planned time frame, and don’t repeatedly reschedule. Interviewees have schedules to keep as well.

4. Take the time to establish what “good” or “great” looks like for this role and share that with each of the interviewers in advance of their meetings. If each interviewer is looking for something different, solid individuals may be unnecessarily excluded from advancing in the process.

5. Respect the person’s confidentiality. Conducting a back door reference on an individual before a first meeting is reckless and lazy. Take the time to form your own opinion of the person. There will be an appropriate time later in the process to validate that opinion.

6. Move expeditiously and only include the necessary stakeholders in the process. Great talent does not stay in the market long, regardless of the hiring climate.

7. Provide extensive information about the company’s culture early on. This allows the individual to pressure-test this in subsequent interviews. If accurate, it will reinforce the message and go a long way toward convincing individuals that the company is a great place to work.

8. Reply to all correspondence. If the individual sends a follow-up thank you email, a simple reply letting them know you received it and wishing them the best of luck in the remainder of the process reinforces that the company appreciates their interest and values them in the process.

9. Do what you say you are going to do. Telling the individual one thing in the interview and then moving forward differently sends mixed signals.  False expectations break trust, especially related to compensation (e.g., low-ball offers).

10. Most important of all, don’t ever ghost an individual. If you do not have anything definitive to share, that’s ok…just communicate this. Talent open to opportunities in the market are typically fine playing the waiting game so long as they feel that the lines of communication are open. When a decision has been made, always close the loop and let the individual know they will not receive an offer. They would prefer to hear this hard message versus not hearing anything at all.

Now, I realize all of this sounds great in a vacuum, but hiring is messy. Things change on a dime. The thing you least expect to happen will often be the most likely thing to happen. Running an optimal process will not be possible one hundred percent of the time. Nonetheless, this should be the goal, and companies should find a way to measure their performance in doing so. Some companies have implemented a brief 3-5 question survey along with a comments section that individuals complete at the end of the process. The data points extracted from these responses are beyond insightful.  Whatever the mechanism, finding a way to monitor the company’s performance in this area is vital to preserving its reputation in the market. We can’t improve what we can’t measure.